Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, March 20, 2013,
In :
EHRC
During debates in the House of Commons and House of Lords
regarding repeal of the EHRC’s ‘General Duty’,
debate centred on the ‘political’ or ‘symbolic’ significance of the duty. It is of course foolish to treat something
with political or symbolic significance as unimportant. As Lord
Low noted during Committee stage in the Lords ‘if its inclusion has
symbolic value, is it not the case that its removal will have symbolic value
also?’ The approach government has sought to t... Continue reading ...
Will Liberal Democrat Ministers sacrifice protection of human rights in the interests of ‘enterprise’?
Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, March 12, 2013,
In :
EHRC
The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill will soon
return to the House of Commons, led by the Liberal Democrat Minister Jo Swinson
MP on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Business Secretary Vince Cable MP.
It seems very probable that the coalition government will
seek to overturn the
amendment to s57 of the Bill won by Baroness Jane Campbell last week and
supported by prominent Liberal Democrat Peers to prevent repeal of the ‘General
Duty’ of the Equality and Human Rights Commission.
T... Continue reading ...
Where now for the Equality and Human Rights Commission?
Posted by Neil Crowther on Sunday, March 10, 2013,
In :
EHRC
I’ve spent the past few months working with
Parliamentarians to seek to put a stop to government plans to repeal the EHRC’s
‘General Duty’. I won’t go back over the
arguments why, but those arguments did prove persuasive last week when the
House of Lords voted 217 – 166 in support of Baroness
Jane Campbell’s amendment to keep the General Duty on the statute
book. The Enterprise and Regulatory
Reform Bill, as amended, now goes back to the House of Commons.
I occupy a peculiar... Continue reading ...
On prisoner votes - beware the long-game
Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, November 20, 2012,
In :
Prisoner votes
Many will feel
morally conflicted about some prisoners having the vote, but it is important to
rise above the noise and recognise that the issue has been primed to achieve other
ends.
Those
calling for a UK Bill of Rights have come to do so under the intellectual
window-dressing of ‘subsidiarity’ – that the protection of human rights should
be primarily a matter for nation States.
This is an entirely respectable aim which should enjoy universal
support. Yet this version of
subsidi... Continue reading ...
Maria Miller, EHRC and a convenient untruth
Posted by Neil Crowther on Friday, November 9, 2012,
In :
EHRC
Maria Miller has written a letter to the Guardian making her case
for reform of the Equality and Human Rights Commission following critical
reports by Hugh
Muir in the wake of some of the existing Commissioners being rejected for
re-appointment. She begins 'Strange goings on would indeed suggest something needs explaining - so perhaps you will let me as secretary of state responsible for women and equalities, explain?'
But she fails to explain, because if she had she would have corrected... Continue reading ...
Why reform of the EHRC’s general duty is an assault on our fundamental rights
Posted by Neil Crowther on Friday, October 19, 2012,
In :
EHRC
In 2006, the UK Parliament willed into
existence a statutory equality and human rights body to encourage and support
the development of a society in which there is respect for the protection and
promotion of each individual’s human rights, for the dignity and worth of each
individual, in which people can achieve their potential unhindered by
discrimination and enjoy equality of opportunity and in which there is mutual
respect between groups.
The ‘general duty’ of the Equality and
Human... Continue reading ...
Disability rights - in need of development: inspiring Labour's welfare reform policy
Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, May 9, 2012,
In :
Welfare reform
At a lecture for the think-tank Demos on 16th May, Shadow Work and Pensions Spokesperson Liam Byrne MP set out Labour's broad approach to modernising the welfare state, while keeping true to the principles of its chief architect William Beveridge. Saying that Labour would focus in particular on disabled people and child poverty, Byrne said that 'our starting point has to be making the rights of persons with disabilities a reality'.
Referencing my recent blog for Disability Rights UK 'Disabili... Continue reading ...
Promoting human rights in the 'something for something society'
I've just returned from an excellent two day conference organised by Just Fair in partnership with the University of Essex, EHRC, Doughty Street Chambers and Law Society Charitable Trust. Big congratulations to Jonny Butterworth and Jamie Burton for organising such an interesting and well attended event. Though 100% committed to the promotion of socio-economic well-being and to overcoming inequality, I remain sceptical about the potential of a rights-based discourse in relation to winning ove... Continue reading ...
Subsidiarity requires action in the 'small places, close to home'
"The big issue is subsidiarity. It is accepted on all sides that the main duty of complying with the European Convention on Human Rights lies on the Government's of the member states"
Justice Secretary, Ken Clarke MP, 2011
The Oxford English dictionary defines 'subsidiarity' as 'the idea that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed effectively at a more immediate or local level'. Intended as a comment on the role of the Euro... Continue reading ...
EHRC launches 'Hidden from Plain View' - the report of its inquiry into disability-related harassment
Before going further I should declare an interest - as Disability Programme Director at the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) I oversaw the work which led to the Commission carrying out its inquiry into disability-related harassment and I was involved in developing the Inquiry terms of reference and reviewing early drafts of today's report.
Many congratulations to Mike Smith, Hilary Mccollum, Jackie Driver, Kathleen Jameson and many other staff at the EHRC. I know it has been a hard... Continue reading ...
Commissioning risks to human rights
An important and worrying survey by the UK Home Care Association highlighting the risks to older people's human rights of ever-shorter home care visits confirms the interim findings of the Equality and Human Rights Commission's formal inquiry into the human rights of older people receiving care at home.
The survey found that home care clients were receiving shorter visits and losing access to services such as safety checks. 82% of 111 UK Councils and health and social care trusts had cut t... Continue reading ...
Protecting human rights in 'open public services'
"We will create a new presumption - backed up by new rights for public service users and a new system of independent ajudication - that public services should be open to a range of providers competing to offer better services" David Cameron
There exist no intrinsic tensions between out-sourcing public services to private and voluntary sector providers and protecting and promoting human rights. State-run services are not safe-havens. In the area of disability rights personalisation and privati... Continue reading ...
|
About Me
| Neil Crowther |
| London, England |
Independent equality and human rights consultant
|