Neil Crowther Consulting - making rights make sense

Showing category "blog" (Show all posts)

Why there should be no right to assisted dying without the right to assisted living

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, May 21, 2013, In : assisted dying 

Assisted dying, or voluntary euthanasia as it was once known before being cleverly re-framed, is a confusing issue.

This is because several different strands of the campaign for voluntary euthanasia are presently underway at once.  In Parliament a Private Members Bill aims to make lawful the giving of assistance to people to bring about their death, but only where they are already very near dying naturally and in 'unbearable suffering'.  In the Courts various people including Tony Nicklinson...


Continue reading ...
 

Bad for human rights and bad for business - why MP’s should err on the side of the Lords on EHRC reform

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, April 15, 2013, In : EHRC 

Writing in the Guardian Newspaper yesterday, Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg said of UK foreign policy that ‘stepping back (from our commitment to human rights) simply for commercial expediency would be walking away from our beliefs.’  Today a Liberal Democrat Minister (Jo Swinson MP) will walk away from her Party’s beliefs and seek to ensure that a central feature of the UK’s domestic human rights protection is repealed – despite the clear will of the House of Lords -  simply for ...


Continue reading ...
 

Promoting prejudice should not be the price of challenging the Work Capability Assessment

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, March 25, 2013, In : Welfare reform 

I don’t know if others share my unease when they read headlines such as brain damaged amputee fit for work, say Atos and see Twitter ignite with indignation?

I would feel equally indignant reading that a person with brain damage who has had a limb amputated – a soldier returning from Afghanistan say – should be presumed to be de facto ‘unfit for work’ for such blanket assumptions, which allow a person to be judged by particular personal characteristics and not their merit, are t...


Continue reading ...
 

Should EHRC's monitoring role be to hold up a mirror to society, or only to itself?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, March 20, 2013, In : EHRC 

During debates in the House of Commons and House of Lords regarding repeal of the EHRC’s ‘General Duty’, debate centred on the ‘political’ or ‘symbolic’ significance of the duty.  It is of course foolish to treat something with political or symbolic significance as unimportant.  As Lord Low noted during Committee stage in the Lords ‘if its inclusion has symbolic value, is it not the case that its removal will have symbolic value also?’ The approach government has sought to t...


Continue reading ...
 

Will Liberal Democrat Ministers sacrifice protection of human rights in the interests of ‘enterprise’?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, March 12, 2013, In : EHRC 

The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill will soon return to the House of Commons, led by the Liberal Democrat Minister Jo Swinson MP on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Business Secretary Vince Cable MP. 

It seems very probable that the coalition government will seek to overturn the amendment to s57 of the Bill won by Baroness Jane Campbell last week and supported by prominent Liberal Democrat Peers to prevent repeal of the ‘General Duty’ of the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

T...


Continue reading ...
 

Where now for the Equality and Human Rights Commission?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Sunday, March 10, 2013, In : EHRC 

I’ve spent the past few months working with Parliamentarians to seek to put a stop to government plans to repeal the EHRC’s ‘General Duty’.  I won’t go back over the arguments why, but those arguments did prove persuasive last week when the House of Lords voted 217 – 166 in support of Baroness Jane Campbell’s amendment to keep the General Duty on the statute book.   The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill, as amended, now goes back to the House of Commons.

I occupy a peculiar...


Continue reading ...
 

House of Lords votes against repeal of EHRC’s general duty

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, March 4, 2013, In : EHRC 

This afternoon (4th March 2013) Peers voted 217-166 in support of Baroness Jane Campbell’s amendment to s57 of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill, opposing the government’s planned repeal of the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s General Duty.   

In addition to Baroness Campbell’s powerful speech a range of impassioned interventions came from all sides of the House including Baroness Thornton, Baroness Lister, Baroness Hollis, Lord Lloyd, Baroness Hussein-Ece and Lord Morr...


Continue reading ...
 

EHRC reform - don't compare an apple with a pear

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, March 4, 2013, In : EHRC 

This afternoon Members of the House of Lords will debate reforms to the Equality and Human Rights Commission.  Baroness Campbell has tabled an amendment opposing the government’s proposal to repeal the 'General Duty' of the EHRC on grounds that doing so will fundamentally change the purpose, role and scope for independent action by the organisation.  The General Duty says that the EHRC ‘shall discharge its functions with a view to encouraging and supporting a society in which:

people's a...


Continue reading ...
 

On disability rights, we shouldn't let a serious crisis go to waste

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, February 25, 2013, In : Independent Living 

we are about to witness the first steps of the dismantling of our dreams of an independent future for all disabled people. The question we need to ask is how did this happen?’

Mike Oliver, Welfare and the wisdom of the past, Disability Now, February 2013 

The brilliance of the social model of disability was always also its inherent weakness: its simplicity.

It was and is too easily read as suggesting that all of the factors excluding disabled people from equal participation in societ...


Continue reading ...
 

Independent living in a time of austerity - a problem or a solution?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Saturday, February 2, 2013, In : Independent Living 

Introduction – independent living in a time of austerity

We start with an apparent dichotomy – the demand to advance disabled people’s right to independent living yet having to do so in the context both of the financial climate we are in and increasing demand for ever more scarce resources as we all live longer lives.

Many of us may disagree with the economic and other policies of the Government in Westminster and their impact at local level – that they are cutting too far, too fast...


Continue reading ...
 

Equality is about more than making empty promises

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, January 17, 2013, In : Equalities 

"We are calling time on equality impact assessments." David Cameron, Prime Minister

"Equality Impact Assessments are not under threat from the Coalition Government" Jo Swinson, Minister for Business, Innovation and Skills

 

Jo Swinson MP’s latest blog (Equality is more than just ticking boxes), apparently written to reassure concerned Liberal Democrats (check out the comments thread – it has failed miserably), exposes the complete lack of coherence – intellectual or otherwise – u...


Continue reading ...
 

The Independent Living Act 2015?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, December 31, 2012, In : Independent Living 

In 2013 we should call for legislation to protect and promote independent living.

The Independent Living Strategy 2009 promised that government would review the case for such legislation ‘if sufficient progress has not been made against the outcomes by 2013’.  The strategy enjoyed cross Party support. There can be little doubt that this test has been met.  Moreover, on many of the outcomes the picture is one of regression.

The final report of the Joint Committee on Human Rights’ (JCH...


Continue reading ...
 

On International Day of Disabled People we should be looking forward, not back

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, December 3, 2012,
Marking the International Day of Disabled People 2012, Kaliya Franklin and Neil Crowther reflect on the UK's proud history of protecting, promoting and fulfilling disabled people's rights and call for a sense of renewed purpose in the face of efforts by government to dismantle many of our most significant achievements.

On disability rights, the UK was the future once - Neil Crowther

 

Continue reading ...
 

When Did We Forget? International Day Of Persons With Disabilities – Kaliya Franklin

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, December 3, 2012, In : International day of disabled people 2012 

Once upon a time Britain led the way in promoting rights and independence for disabled people. That was the country I grew up in; I remember the horror when conditions for disabled children in foreign orphanages were exposed, pitiful little bundles of bones often tied to their cots, staring vacantly at their bars and walls, wizened like ancient beings who'd seen nothing but cruelty their entire lives. 

I remember ramps being built, institutions shut down, rights being created, laws being ma...


Continue reading ...
 

On disability rights, the UK was the future once.

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, December 3, 2012, In : International day of disabled people 2012 

Today, 3 December, is the United Nations International Day of Persons with Disabilities.  Observed since 1992, the day aims to promote an understanding of disability issues and build respect for the dignity, rights and well-being of disabled people around the world.  It also seeks to increase awareness of gains to be derived from the integration of disabled people in every aspect of political, social, economic and cultural life.   Marking this year’s international day, the UN Secretary Gene...


Continue reading ...
 

Amid the gloom, some good news for disability rights

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, November 28, 2012, In : Education and disability 
It was sad that the political storm over the complete failure of the work programme obscured some rather good news included in the Joseph Rowntree Foundation's 'Monitoring Poverty and Social Exclusion 2012'.  

It found that the percentage of 19 year-olds with a disability who did not have a level 3 qualification fell by 21% from 74% in 2000 to 53% in 2010, compared to 42% of non disabled 19 year olds.  The fall has also been much faster than for non-disabled people age 19, closing the gap from...

Continue reading ...
 

A manifesto for comprehensive welfare reform

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, November 27, 2012, In : Welfare reform 

Disabled people enrich our country in many significant ways - as parents and carers, community activists and teachers, sportsmen and women, local councillors and Ministers of State, as leaders of business, inventors, academics and scientists, musicians, actors, writers and artists.    Through their active contribution, disabled people generate wealth, strengthen families and communities, educate and entertain and help our country to progress.

Like the majority of people, all most disabled pe...


Continue reading ...
 

Labour should be proud of its record on disability rights – it should not turn back the clock over Remploy

Posted by Neil Crowther on Saturday, November 24, 2012, In : Remploy 

What are we to make of the fact that only 35 of the 1000 ex-employees of recently closed Remploy factories have so far found new employment?

Liam Byrne deduces that it is a consequence of the lack of jobs in the economy and therefore the decent thing to do is to halt further closures.  

This would suggest that in a more buoyant economy the figure would be far higher. Yet there is little evidence that many more ex-factory workers found work following the closure of 28 factories under Labour ...


Continue reading ...
 

On prisoner votes - beware the long-game

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, November 20, 2012, In : Prisoner votes 

Many will feel morally conflicted about some prisoners having the vote, but it is important to rise above the noise and recognise that the issue has been primed to achieve other ends.   

Those calling for a UK Bill of Rights have come to do so under the intellectual window-dressing of ‘subsidiarity’ – that the protection of human rights should be primarily a matter for nation States.  This is an entirely respectable aim which should enjoy universal support.  Yet this version of subsidi...


Continue reading ...
 

What has the EHRC ever done for us?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, November 13, 2012, In : EHRC 

Last week Minister for Women and Equalities, Maria Miller wrote to the Guardian newspaper to ‘explain’ (read: misinform) why the government wished to focus the EHRC on its ‘unique role’, which it has conveniently discovered will only require a quarter of its original budget to deliver.  It was good to see the Commission fight back, but they desperately need people to rally to their cause and resist reforms which – irrespective of what you feel about the Commission’s past performan...


Continue reading ...
 

Maria Miller, EHRC and a convenient untruth

Posted by Neil Crowther on Friday, November 9, 2012, In : EHRC 

Maria Miller has written a letter to the Guardian making her case for reform of the Equality and Human Rights Commission following critical reports by Hugh Muir in the wake of some of the existing Commissioners being rejected for re-appointment.    She begins 'Strange goings on would indeed suggest something needs explaining - so perhaps you will let me as secretary of state responsible for women and equalities, explain?' 

But she fails to explain, because if she had she would have corrected...


Continue reading ...
 

Only through learning to trust will we genuinely reform welfare

Posted by Neil Crowther on Sunday, October 21, 2012, In : Welfare reform 

Behind some subtle differences in rhetoric and degree, there is little to distinguish the attitudes and approach of the major parties towards disability and welfare.  Here’s Ed Miliband in his Party Conference speech:

‘You see I think it is incredibly important that to be One Nation we must show compassion and support for all those who cannot work. Particularly the disabled men and women of our country. But in order to do so, those who can work have a responsibility to do so. We can’t ...


Continue reading ...
 

Why reform of the EHRC’s general duty is an assault on our fundamental rights

Posted by Neil Crowther on Friday, October 19, 2012, In : EHRC 

In 2006, the UK Parliament willed into existence a statutory equality and human rights body to encourage and support the development of a society in which there is respect for the protection and promotion of each individual’s human rights, for the dignity and worth of each individual, in which people can achieve their potential unhindered by discrimination and enjoy equality of opportunity and in which there is mutual respect between groups.

The ‘general duty’ of the Equality and Human...


Continue reading ...
 

One Nation should welcome disabled people as equals not render them objects.

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, October 2, 2012,
Ed Miliband's Labour Conference speech was a masterclass in value-laden communications, pressing button after carefully polled button to draw together a narrative of 'one nation Labour'.  So far so good. I find it appeals to my own sense of what is wrong and how it needs to be put right. And then...

....And then came this: 'You see I think it is incredibly important that to be One Nation we must show compassion and support for all those who cannot work. Particularly the disabled men and women ...

Continue reading ...
 

What the disability hate crime statistics really reveal is huge disparities in the performance of police authorities across the UK

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, September 13, 2012, In : disability-related-harassment 
Figures published today concerning the number of recorded disability hate crimes in the UK in 2011 - that is, crimes recognised and recorded by the police - show a rise of 1/3 since 2010. But despite widespread reports, including by the BBC, what they do not necessarily themselves show is a rise in the incidence of hostility towards disabled people.  

This is not to suggest that the incidence of hostility towards disabled people hasn't risen in the intervening period, or that the rise in recor...

Continue reading ...
 

To eliminate hostility towards disabled people we must cut the deficit

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, July 16, 2012, In : disability-related-harassment 
Read my new guest post for Disability Rights UK  
Continue reading ...
 

Those defending Remploy are employing popular prejudice towards disabled people for political gain

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, July 10, 2012, In : Remploy 
The most ugly aspect of the closure of Remploy factories is the way the issue is being exploited for political gain for reasons entirely unconnected either to the well-being of the workers who will be made redundant or to the lives of disabled people more generally.  

The buttons being pressed here stem from 'malevolence benevolence' - prejudice disguised as 'compassion'.  By playing on pity, the opposition can characterise the government as uncaring and nasty - scoring political points along ...

Continue reading ...
 

10 things you should know about the government's proposals to reform the EHRC

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, July 2, 2012,

The Home Office recently published its response to the response to its consultation on reform of the Equality and Human Rights Commission.  Here are 10 things people should note regarding the Government’s plans:

The government's plans fundamentally change the nature and purpose of the Commission.  

By repealing section 3 of the Equality Act 2006 the Commission will cease to be agent of social change harnessing the law and its powers to address entrenched inequalities. Instead (insofar as ...


Continue reading ...
 

A right to vote should be part of the pathway back to citizenship for some prisoners

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, June 28, 2012, In : Prisoner votes 
It's deeply depressing that parts of the Government and opposition have set themselves on a collision course with the European Court of Human Rights over the question of prisoner votes rather than devise and debate a proportionate response to the Courts judgement.  Defying the rule of law in this way presents a dangerous 'slippery slope' for human rights protection in the UK. Such posturing is also already giving comfort to routine human rights violators such as Russia and Turkey while underm...
Continue reading ...
 

Baroness Campbell goes nuclear...or does she?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, June 13, 2012, In : JCHR 
Yesterday at a joint meeting between the Minister for Disabled People Maria Miller and the various disability-focused All Party Parliamentary Groups, Baroness Campbell was heard to liken government policies on disability to 'building a nuclear power station on a fault-line without thinking what would happen if there were an earthquake'.

Now I may have misheard what Baroness Campbell said because the line was already formed in my head, having discussed it with Jane.  It may have got lost in del...

Continue reading ...
 

In another world...will court uphold right of prisoner not to vote?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Saturday, June 9, 2012, In : Prisoner votes 
The Government's controversial compulsory voting law, introduced following Simon Cowell's inquiry into record low turnout at the last General Election is facing legal challenge from a prisoner serving a 25 year sentence for armed robbery.

Bob Burst from Hull, East Yorkshire is arguing that the law discriminates against him because his incarceration denies him the opportunity to assess and scrutinise the proposals of the various political parties and to engage freely in democratic debate. "With...

Continue reading ...
 

Rights to independent living - the long journey ahead

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, June 7, 2012, In : United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
Last November I worked with Professor Anna Lawson at Leeds University to draft a report for the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights synthesising evidence collected from people with intellectual disabilities and people with mental health conditions across nine EU countries - Sweden, UK, Bulgaria, France, Latvia, Romania, Greece and Germany - regarding their experience of living independently and being included in the community.  

Today (7/6/12) the EUFRA has published the final report ...

Continue reading ...
 

Equality impact assessments and why accountability sometimes hides the truth

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, June 6, 2012, In : Equalities 
In his fascinating book 'The Righteous Mind' Jonathan Haidt provides evidence to show how people think more systematically and self critically when they know in advance that they will have to explain themselves.  To this end, the duty to publish equality impact assessments should help serve to ensure that policy makers and decision-takers reflect properly on the equality implications of options under consideration.  

However, evidence also finds that there are different types of careful reason...

Continue reading ...
 

Obama transmits UNCRPD to Senate for ratification

Posted by Neil Crowther on Sunday, May 20, 2012, In : United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
Presidential message below:

 Floor Action: May 17, 2012 - Received in the Senate and referred to the Committee on Foreign Relations by unanimous consent removing the injunction of secrecy. 

Resolution: THE WHITE HOUSE, 

May 17, 2012.

TO THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES: I transmit herewith, for advice and consent of the Senate to its ratification, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on December 13, 2006, and signed by the United...

Continue reading ...
 

Why is Iain Duncan Smith promoting dependency?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, May 14, 2012, In : Welfare reform 
Iain Duncan Smith aims to reduce the number's receiving Disability Living Allowance's replacement the 'Personal Independence Payment' by 500,000 'in a bid to combat fraud and abuse'.   It's tempting to trot out official government statistics regarding DLA and fraud (less and half of 1% if you're interested, so around 15000) but this is to re-enforce the government's framing of the issue, employed by Duncan-Smith and hungrily supported by various media organs.  
 
Recognise instead that disabled...

Continue reading ...
 

Disability rights - in need of development: inspiring Labour's welfare reform policy

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, May 9, 2012, In : Welfare reform 
At a lecture for the think-tank Demos on 16th May, Shadow Work and Pensions Spokesperson Liam Byrne MP set out Labour's broad approach to modernising the welfare state, while keeping true to the principles of its chief architect William Beveridge.  Saying that Labour would focus in particular on disabled people and child poverty, Byrne said that 'our starting point has to be making the rights of persons with disabilities a reality'.

Referencing my recent blog for Disability Rights UK 'Disabili...
Continue reading ...
 

Seminar on the Joint Committee on Human Rights Report on disabled people's right to independent living

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, March 29, 2012, In : United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
On 21st March 2012, Baroness Jane Campbell, a cross bench peer and member of the UK Joint Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights hosted a seminar concerning the Committee's report of its inquiry into the implementation of disabled people's right to independent living.   You can access the slides from the presentation here 

Unfortunately, Baroness Campbell was unwell on the day and unable to attend, but she sent the following message:

Message from Baroness Jane Campbell                         ...


Continue reading ...
 

No more defending the indefensible

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, March 12, 2012, In : Welfare reform 
My guest blog on why disabled people should be promoting radical reform of the Welfare State: http://disabilityrightsuk.blogspot.com/2012/03/no-more-defending-indefensible.html
Continue reading ...
 

Change is painful, but the Government has got it right on Remploy and specialist employment support

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, March 7, 2012, In : Remploy 
The reaction to today's announcement regarding the closure of 36 of the remaining 54 Remploy factories was predictable, coming hot on the heels of the Welfare Reform Act receiving Royal Assent.   

However, the redeployment of resources presently tied up in Remploy factories to be used to support disabled people into open employment was and is the right course.  Remploy factories employ around 2,800 disabled people, at an annual cost of around £22,700 per person (a total of around £63 million...

Continue reading ...
 

Joint Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights publishes report on disabled people's right to independent living

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, March 1, 2012, In : United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
In a world-first, the UK's Parliament has conducted an inquiry into the UK Government's implementation of Article19 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities - the right to live independently and to be included in the community.   I was honoured to work as a specialist adviser to the Joint Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights on the Inquiry which began in 2011 and received evidence from over 300 witnesses.

Dr Hywel Francis MP, Chair of the Committee, said: ...

Continue reading ...
 

International Day of Disabled People - developed countries take note

Posted by Neil Crowther on Saturday, December 3, 2011, In : Development 
Today is the international day of persons with disabilities.  The official theme of the day is 'including persons with disabilities in development'.  Given 1 in 7 people in the world have a disability, and most live in developing countries, it is self-evident that international ambitions such as the Millennium Development Goals and Education for All will not be achieved without placing disability rights at the centre of development.

The focus on development will no doubt lead many in developed...

Continue reading ...
 

What the Underground map looks like if you can't use stairs - by www.transportforall.org.uk

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, November 29, 2011, In : Accessibility and inclusive design 

Continue reading ...
 

Promoting human rights in the 'something for something society'

Posted by Neil Crowther on Saturday, October 22, 2011, In : Economic, social and cultural rights 
I've just returned from an excellent two day conference organised by Just Fair in partnership with the University of Essex, EHRC, Doughty Street Chambers and Law Society Charitable Trust. Big congratulations to Jonny Butterworth and Jamie Burton for organising such an interesting and well attended event. 

Though 100% committed to the promotion of socio-economic well-being and to overcoming inequality, I remain sceptical about the potential of a rights-based discourse in relation to winning ove...
Continue reading ...
 

Withholding Access to Work from central government departments has put a cap on disabled civil servants careers

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, October 6, 2011, In : Access to work 
Jane Cordell is a diplomat working for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO).  Between 2006 and January 2010 she was First Secretary at the British Embassy in Warsaw.  She applied for and was offered the post of Deputy Head of Mission in Kazakhstan.  

Jane is deaf and employs the services of a full time lip speaker to perform her role, support she enjoyed throughout her time in Warsaw.  However, while in Warsaw the FCO had amended its policy on reasonable adjustments, requiring 'special co...

Continue reading ...
 

Has the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities re-written Article 33.2?

Posted by Neil Crowther on Tuesday, October 4, 2011, In : United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 
Read my guest blog-post on the excellent new 'Disability and Human Rights' site http://disabilityandhumanrights.com/2011/10/04/has-the-un-committee-on-the-rights-of-persons-with-disabilities-re-written-article-33-2/

 

Continue reading ...
 

Subsidiarity requires action in the 'small places, close to home'

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, September 26, 2011, In : Defending the Human Rights Act 
"The big issue is subsidiarity.  It is accepted on all sides that the main duty of complying with the European Convention on Human Rights lies on the Government's of the member states"

Justice Secretary, Ken Clarke MP, 2011


The Oxford English dictionary defines 'subsidiarity' as 'the idea that a central authority should have a subsidiary function, performing only those tasks which cannot be performed effectively at a more immediate or local level'.  Intended as a comment on the role of the Euro...

Continue reading ...
 

Why UNITE is wrong on Remploy

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, September 15, 2011,
Tomorrow (16th September 2011), UNITE members plan to picket the offices of RADAR in protest at the recommendations of the review by its Director Liz Sayce, commissioned by the government, regarding specialist employment support.  Their beef is with the report's proposals for a gradual re-allocation of resources tied up in sheltered employment (and Remploy specifically) towards supporting people to find work in the mainstream jobs market. 

Remploy factories employ around 2,800 disabled people,...

Continue reading ...
 

Why the language of 'hate' should not take over from the language of 'vulnerability'

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, September 12, 2011, In : Disability related harassment 
The EHRC launched the report of its inquiry into disability related harassment on 12th September 2011.  The inquiry followed research into disability related harassment which I commissioned when I was Disability Director at the EHRC and I was involved in setting the Inquiry terms of reference. 

From the moment I became involved in this issue (as Head of Policy at the Disability Rights Commission) and no doubt before, the thorny (and persistent) policy and practice of classifying disabled peopl...

Continue reading ...
 

EHRC launches 'Hidden from Plain View' - the report of its inquiry into disability-related harassment

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, September 12, 2011, In : Disability related harassment 
Before going further I should declare an interest - as Disability Programme Director at the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) I oversaw the work which led to the Commission carrying out its inquiry into disability-related harassment and I was involved in developing the Inquiry terms of reference and reviewing early drafts of today's report.

Many congratulations to Mike Smith, Hilary Mccollum, Jackie Driver, Kathleen Jameson and many other staff at the EHRC.  I know it has been a hard...

Continue reading ...
 

Commissioning risks to human rights

Posted by Neil Crowther on Wednesday, September 7, 2011, In : Human rights in open public services 
An important and worrying survey by the UK Home Care Association highlighting the risks to older people's human rights of ever-shorter home care visits confirms the interim findings of the Equality and Human Rights Commission's formal inquiry into the human rights of older people receiving care at home.   

The survey found that home care clients were receiving shorter visits and losing access to services such as safety checks.  82% of 111 UK Councils and health and social care trusts had cut t...
Continue reading ...
 

The Low Review: Disabled people living in residential care homes deserve greater freedom, not less

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, September 5, 2011,

In 2009 the UK Government ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD). Article 19 of the Convention concerns the right of disabled people to live independently in the community and requires government to put in place legal and practical measures to enable disabled people to exercise choice about where and with who they live and to overcome isolation through increased participation in community life. 

Clearly Disability Living Allowance and its suc...
Continue reading ...
 

The English Defence League and the 'paradox of tolerance'

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, September 5, 2011, In : Freedom of expression 
The banning of last weekend's (3rd September 2011) planned march by the English Defence League (via the means of banning all marches within the vicinity of Tower Hamlets during the period) has prompted much debate concerning where the limits of freedom of expression lie, it at all.  

 By chance, I happened upon the 'Paradox of Tolerance' by Karl Popper: 

 "Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance.  If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we a...

Continue reading ...
 

Protecting human rights in 'open public services'

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, August 1, 2011, In : Human rights in open public services 

"We will create a new presumption - backed up by new rights for public service users and a new system of independent ajudication - that public services should be open to a range of providers competing to offer better services"

David Cameron

There exist no intrinsic tensions between out-sourcing public services to private and voluntary sector providers and protecting and promoting human rights.  State-run services are not safe-havens.  In the area of disability rights personalisation and privati...

Continue reading ...
 

Education, disability and social policy

Posted by Neil Crowther on Monday, July 18, 2011, In : Education and disability 
Congratulations to Steve Haines and David Ruebain for editing an excellent compendium of essays regarding the future of education and disability.  I was really pleased to be asked to contribute a chapter to the book which explored how taking a 'capabilities approach' might move the agenda of disabled children's education along from the sterile 'special v mainstream' debate it so often gets stuck in.  I called it from SEN to Sen - geddit??

It's available from the Policy Press for the highly rea...

Continue reading ...
 

Why the Human Rights Act isn't there to be loved

Posted by Neil Crowther on Thursday, July 7, 2011, In : Defending the Human Rights Act 
One of the final activities I was involved in before leaving the Equality and Human Rights Commission was the release of interim findings from the Commission's Inquiry into the human rights of older people receiving care in their own homes.  These deeply worrying findings received huge media coverage.  In doing so they also appeared to achieve something many human rights advocates had long sought - a popular media story which enjoyed universal support for the importance of human rights includ...
Continue reading ...
 
 

About Me


Independent equality and human rights consultant
blog comments powered by Disqus